Register Forgot your password?

Ellen DeGeneres Quits American Idol, Kara DioGuardi Fired! Jennifer Lopez & Steven Tyler To Replace Them

MAJOR shake ups in the American Idol judging line up.  Ellen DeGeneres announced late yesterday that she has quit the show, after just a year.

In a statement released to multiple media outlets, Ellen stated, “A couple months ago, I let FOX and the American Idol producers know that this didn’t feel like the right fit for me. I told them I wouldn’t leave them in a bind and that I would hold off on doing anything until they were able to figure out where they wanted to take the panel next.”

Ellen, 52, replaced Paula Abdul as a judge for the show’s ninth season.  “It was a difficult decision to make, but my work schedule became more than I bargained for,” her statement continues, before adding that “it was hard for me to judge people and sometimes hurt their feelings.”

The AI news did not end there as TMZ then confirmed this morning that fellow judge Kara DioGuardi has been fired, and that the show will be going back to a three-judge format.


Jennifer LopezSteven Tyler

And who will be replacing Ellen and Kara on the judging panel?  According to GossipCop and TMZ, it will be none other than Jennifer Lopez aka Jlo and rocker Steven Tyler.

GossipCop was the first to report the news, when they ran a story last night stating that American Idol had offered the two spots to both Jlo and Steven.

TMZ also confirmed this morning that assuming all deals are finalized, the judge’s panel will consist of Randy Jackson, Jennifer Lopez and Steven Tyler. Adding that the only way Kara will get her job back is if Jlo rejects the offer.

American Idol is reportedly hoping to announce their new judging line up on Monday.

TELL US: WHAT ARE YOUR THOUGHTS ON THE CHANGES IN THE AI JUDGING LINEUP?




46 Responses so far | Have Your Say!

  1. LOL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  2. Steven Tyler looks awful.

  3. @maryJane

    It’s because he is the undead.

  4. Good im glad she is gone I couldn’t stand looking at her and those damm elf ears of her
    She is a bit creepy looking. Hard partying hasn’t fared well on ol Steven he still a hell of a singer

  5. @Zoso, but what about Jlo she is a barely capable actress and if you ever heard her sing without all the special effects!?!?!

    Its the butt that will do all the judging!

  6. @3 Bryan.. LOL!

    I have no interest in JLo whatsoever, but Steven Tyler is a great choice!

  7. Here is Dlisted always hysterical take on this latest thing

    http://www.dlisted.com/node/38236

  8. This show is finished. Simon Cowell was the show and crazy Paula and Randy had the right chemistry. The others, not so much.

  9. JLo? Seriously?! I don’t care for her acting or “singing”. I like Steve Tyler. He actually knows how to sing. Think he should have gone with purple and black striped pants though.

  10. #8~I agree. Simon, Paula and Randy had the right chemistry and added to this show. Time for AI to end its run. IMO.

  11. My mistake. Meant Steven Tyler.

    Agree that Simon, Paula, and Randy had the right chemistry. I always had great laughs when Paula was on.

  12. @ 5 Bryan
    I never cared for Jlo all she is famous for is having a fat ass and dating P-Diddy who in my opinion got rich exploiting Biggie after he died also her acting skills sucks and I don’t listen to her music so I’m sure she sucks at that too

  13. This show will just not be the same without Simon….love or hate him, his criticisms were always on point. Without him the show is going to feel like someone let all the air out of the room.

    I did not like Kara……she never won me over and as for Ellen, I always thought the she was out of her element.

    I think Scary Spice would have been a better addition instead of J-Lo. We need some real personality here.

    I like Steven, let’s just hope that his personal demons don’t take over during the show.

  14. 14
    help me rhonda

    Will Steven Tyler even remember he is on the show and show up each week?

  15. IMO…this show has jumped the shark…

    With luck, this will be the last season…

  16. When I first read about Ellen leaving American Idol my initial thought was “please take Kara with you!” Fingers crossed that Kara will not be back. The woman could never stop running her mouth and acted as if she was the “star” of the show. I recall one show where Simon tried to tell Kara to shut up and she took offense stating that she was there to give constructive criticism. So true – but – what Kara said in 100 words someone else could say it in 10.

  17. 17
    SweetCakes

    Steven Tyler looks more like a woman than JLo! LMAO!! :D

  18. Dude looks like a lady

  19. did not see this coming. WOW

  20. Steven Tyler actually looks a little like Kelly Bensimone

  21. I want my Paula backkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk that is all i get to say about this.

  22. I cannot stand Jennifer Lopez!! She lacks ALOT in the the personality department!!! Guess I won’t be watching Idol anymore.

  23. J.lo and steve tylor plzzzzzzzzzzzz yeah right that would work common people the show is dying it is the end of American idol. Simon left nothing left for American Idol.

  24. @15LuvsMe sorry to bother u but u are my teacher when it comes phrases so what IMO means??

  25. IMO is In My Opinion
    IMHO is In My Humble Opinion

  26. @carmen thank u very much, excuse my ignorance I am not fanilier some of the phrases we use in here.
    xoxox

  27. i meant familier

  28. AI has officially jumped the shark. The worst decision of all time. I hope they lose a TON of viewers.

    J.Lo is a skank who is a divider and a major pain in the ass diva.

    Steven Tyler – what can you say? He’s right out of the “Mardi Gras” episode of the Twilight Zone.

  29. I haven’t watched Idol since Kelly won. I am so over the show because it’s too much of the same. The Idol singers barely make it into the business. How many have actually had success and continue to be successful?

    It’s kind of like the Rocky movies. How many more times can we see the same thing. ONE IDOL was ENOUGH!

  30. Damn, Steven Tyler looks like a corpse!

  31. I guess Kara’s strip tease number wasn’t a hit w/ middle america. Maybe she can rip off her dress on a local cable station now.

    Steven Tyler needs to drop the QVC women’s attire. He’s WAY too old to wear boutique items, not to mention the highlights and airbrushed makeup.

  32. 32
    RealitySuxs

    They are really scraping the bottom of the barrel. They are
    making this show about the judges, and its supposed to be about the contestants.

    I stopped watching IDOL a long time ago … and with this edition of “new judges”, I see no reason to return as a viewer.

  33. I am not surprised by this. Allow I love Ellen American Idol was not for her. Kara didn’t really add much.

    It will be interesting to see what Jennifer and Steven bring to the table.

    It’s not an easy job. It just looks that way.

  34. 34
    Aguardiente

    Jennifer Lopez judging anyone’s singing ability is the equivalent of RHWNJ’s Teresa handing out financial advice. This show is done.

  35. What?? This show is such a joke now. Steven Tyler is replacing Simon Cowel? Right.
    I like Kara. Why can’t she stay and they bring in someone to replace Simon?
    This makes no sense at all!

  36. WOW I mean WOW speachless Can this be real? WOW

    Here we go diwnheal ( spelling ) my bad

    WOW just WOW can you get any lower? w

    wo2w

  37. posted this when first broke ( see douw for the 30th ) WOW, again WOW did not see this coming. Can’t speak Shock

  38. @Nimeo, You’re welcome. Gotta start somewhere, right! You’ll like it hear- lots of fun and lots of great opinions! Enjoy!

  39. Steven Tylor is SOOOOOOOO ugly I can’t bare to watch AI this season…… I think they shoul have new judges every year

  40. Ellen did not quit. Was fired. She was not talented. Was a flak.

  41. I didn’t realize Jennifer Lopez’s Hollywood career had fallen so far and Tyler really needs to lay off the Botox.

  42. Think think this show has ran its course.

    J-Lo???? – Glad she has a happy home life w/hubby & kids but don’t think she is very talented. Perhaps she can judge based on her perseverance in pursuing stardom.

    The Kara gal – never understood who she was, where she came from & why she was on the show.

  43. I have to watch just to see if Steven remembers where he is and speaks coherently! Actually, I LOVE Steven and Aerosmith, but this is a bizarre choice, IMO.

    J Jo? OMG, what an untalented wannabe! She will make the show all about “me,me, me”. Gawd, I hope she doesn’t drag her boring husband on there with her.

    I liked Kara better when Paula was there. I really,really, really miss Paula…….she was the heart of the show.

    Love Randy!

    Absolutely love Simon, and I’m not sure the show can go on without him.

    It will be darn near impossible to recreate the chemistry that Simon, Paula and Randy had.

    I was hoping for Howard Stern, at least it would have been really interesting then. And it crossed my mind often that Harry Connick, Jr. would be a great judge. Bret Michaels would have been decent too, but they couldn’t have had any blond female contestants on the show, too much liability, lol.

    Bottom line, Tyler might be okay, at least he’s relevant and has major talent. But J Lo? C’mon, that’s scraping the bottom of the barrel.

    American Idol has jumped the shark, I’m afraid.

  44. Maybe American Idol should have a different celebrity guest judge each week instead of saddling us for an entire season with J Lo. I remember when Neil Patrick Harris judged during the auditions, and I thought he did a great job. And Shania Twain was hysterical, she could almost become a trainwreck, I do believe! Maybe Mary Jo Blige, Elton John, Rob Thomas, Bret Michaels, Rod Stewart, etc. could each sit in for one or two episodes…………just a thought. I hate to see AI go off air because it is such a good vehicle for these budding artists to at least get some exposure. Oh well, they didn’t ask me.

  45. Jennifer Lopez still maintains her excellent curved figure. She is an amazing woman. She is beautiful and sexy. I hope I can see her in person

  46. Jennifer Lopez is fantastic with her dance moves. I love all her music videos. She is almost perfect. The face, the body, the style and taste in fashion. I adore her