The timeline of this Summer House scandal just got even muddier. Mia Alario from Southern Hospitality just went on Watch What Happens Live and claimed that Amanda Batula and West Wilson were spending alone time together all the way back in September 2025.
If true, it would directly contradict the timeline that West shared, claiming that their relationship blossomed in February. So, who’s telling the truth?
The Bravo star has called West Wilson and Amanda Batula’s timeline into question
Mia and West went on a date in New York City back in September, and Andy Cohen couldn’t help but ask her about it during her recent appearance on WWHL.
Looking back on the date, Mia said that they had a fun time, but it was a conversation she had with Amanda two months later at BravoCon that gave her pause.
“I met Amanda at BravoCon, and she told me that they actually pregamed our date at his apartment,” Mia recalled.
She continued, “At the time, I’m like, ‘Oh, you’re such a good friend. That sounds like such a good time.’”
Knowing what we all know now about West and Amanda, Mia is looking back on that conversation with more scrutiny. Why was Amanda pregaming with West at his apartment? According to Mia, Amanda told her that she gave West “some advice and some tips” before the date.
Mia added, “I was like, girl, did we get the same tip or what?”
Andy quipped, “Just the tip.”
Earlier this week, West’s Summer House pal Jesse Solomon went on WWHL and reiterated to Andy that, from his perspective, things seemed to start heating up between West and Amanda back in February. However, Mia’s new detail seems to directly dispute that timeline, and it adds fuel to the ongoing theory that Scamanda was happening long before anyone knew.
After spilling all of this tea, Mia wrapped things up by saying she wants nothing to do with this mess. There’s plenty of drama on Southern Hospitality for her to handle.
Mia concluded, “Now looking back at it, it’s a messy situation. I don’t want any part of that.”
Summer House airs on Tuesdays at 8/7c on Bravo. You can catch Southern Hospitality on Wednesdays at 9/8c. They’re both streaming on Peacock.
TELL US – WHAT ARE YOUR THOUGHTS ON MIA’S NEW TEA ABOUT AMANDA AND WEST? DO YOU THINK THEIR RELATIONSHIP STARTED BEFORE FEBRUARY?
