When things don’t work out, you try and try again. That’s what Golden Bachelor Gerry Turner is doing. When things didn’t work out with Theresa Nist, he allegedly gave another one of the women he met on his Golden Bachelor season another shot at love.
Gerry and Theresa found love on the show in 2023 and were engaged in the same year. By January 2024, the couple was married. Then by June 2024, they were divorced. It wasn’t the ideal ending, but they both soldiered on.
Gerry Turner dated another woman from The Golden Bachelor after his divorce from Theresa Nist
Gerry initially said that he wasn’t dating after the divorce and that he was going to focus on himself more. He did see someone after their separation in April and even gave Theresa a heads-up about it. But it didn’t become anything.
Now, Theresa and some of the other women from Gerry’s season alleged that he dated another contestant from the show.
During the August 20 episode of the Bachelor Happy Hour podcast, Theresa spoke with fellow Golden Bachelor alums Kathy Swarts and Susan Noles. When the topic inevitably came around to Gerry, Susan mentioned that he dated another fellow contestant after he and Theresa split up.
“I think you know Gerry dated Christina from our show for a while after?” Susan asked. Theresa replied that she knew NOW. She also admitted that she was the one who suggested that Gerry go out with Christina, a retired purchasing manager from Sierra Madre, California.
“They went out for like six months,” Kathy said. The length of their relationship surprised Theresa. While it remains unclear when exactly they dated, it also didn’t last. Gerry has since moved on and has been dating someone named Lana since March 2025, although marriage is still far from Gerry’s mind, according to PEOPLE.
As for Theresa, she confirmed that she is also not dating anyone at the moment. She did admit that she was curious about what Gerry was going to be saying in his upcoming memoir. It looks like they aren’t in touch enough for her to get a heads-up on that.
TELL US – WILL GERRY BE THE WORST GOLDEN BACHELOR?
