Andy Cohen has spoken, and the mystery that haunted us all during Real Housewives of Salt Lake City Season 3 is going to be solved. Yes, the Heather Gay black eye that rocked the Bravoverse will finally be explained! Or at least, that’s what Andy promised on a recent edition of Watch What Happens Live.
In fact, Andy may have already given the game away. Writer Danny Pellegrino joined RHOSLC star Lisa Barlow in those famous clubhouse chairs, and asked Zaddy Cohen, “Did we confirm that the black eye was done by Jen Shah?”
Who’s responsible for Heather Gay’s black eye?
Andy quickly responded, “Well, we think so, and we’re gonna find out later this season.” Too many shots this episode, Andy? You’re not supposed to give the answer away before the episode airs! Rookie mistake. But it’s something we all saw coming, right? The criminal did it! Shocker!
“Have we got proof of it?” Danny followed up, but by that point, Andy’s lips were sealed. He shrugged, and started playing with his tie and ring. Probably pissed at himself for giving the game away. The conversation quickly moved on to old school reunion looks, which was definitely not as exciting as this latest development.
Of course, there’s still plenty to look forward to. If Jen gave Heather a black eye, exactly WHY did she do it? Will we see footage that was left on the cutting room floor during Season 3? Did editors go back through everything all over again and piece the mystery together? Are we going to get a 10-part Netflix true crime series based on the events? Only time will tell!
For now, The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City Season 4 continues Tuesdays at 8/7c on Bravo.
TELL US – WOULD JEN GIVING HEATHER THE BLACK EYE SHOCK YOU? IF SHE DID DO IT, WHAT COULD THE REASON BE? ARE YOU ENJOYING RHOSLC SEASON 4?