If Season 10 of Vanderpump Rules taught us anything, it’s that secrets don’t stay buried for long. And when they do, it’s usually because someone buried them on purpose. That brings us to Scheana Shay, who now finds herself in the hot seat for keeping quiet about something major: Brock Davies cheating on her.
While whispers about Brock’s fidelity have been circulating online for years, fans were shocked to learn that Scheana seemingly knew about the incident and chose not to say anything until after filming wrapped. No podcast confessionals. No emotional breakdowns in the alley behind SUR. Just silence. And now that it’s out there? The whole thing feels a little bit off. Let’s talk about why Scheana’s decision to stay silent on Brock’s biggest scandal yet is raising eyebrows. And whether it was damage control or just denial.
It seems strange that Scheana Shay kept Brock Davies cheating a secret
Scheana has never been shy about sharing her personal life. This is the same woman who documented her wedding, a divorce, her fertility journey, her postpartum struggles, and even her husband’s love of budgie smugglers (IFKYK). So when news broke that Brock had stepped out on the marriage and Scheana allegedly knew about it, it felt completely out of character for her to stay quiet. According to her Glamour article, Scheana found out about the cheating during or shortly after Season 11 filming. Yet there was no mention of it on the show, no hint in her social media posts, and no mention on Scheananigans until well after the season ended. For someone who always claims to keep it real,” this level of silence doesn’t track.
Fans are accustomed to Scheana being messy in a lovable, oversharing manner. She’s the girl who will cry over telling Brandi Glanville the truth. So why suddenly go quiet when your husband is cheating? But moreover, why bring up a PR storm when no one had any idea? The most generous reading is that she was protecting her daughter, Summer Moon. But that theory goes out the window after she revealed the scandal. The more skeptical take? She was protecting the Brock brand and herself.
The timing for the reveal is a bit suspect
If you’re going to talk about a cheating scandal, timing is everything. And in this case? The timing is calculated. The infidelity only came to light after the season aired and the cast did their post-season podcast rounds. Scheana addressed the rumors vaguely, hinting at trust issues, which she blamed wholeheartedly on Scandoval. So why now? Some fans believe Scheana waited to reveal the cheating because she was preparing to drop her new memoir. The Good as Gold singer loves the spotlight! I can only imagine she wanted all the press she could get when it came to plugging her book. What better bait to fans than chumming the waters with Brock cheating?
Honestly, if I were Brock, I would be pissed my wife was using our issues as fodder. But that is on brand for Sheesh. With the Scandoval fallout dominating every episode, it could be that Scheana learned a valuable lesson in marketing. Maybe Scheana thought dropping the bomb after the fact would reignite interest. Maybe it was a soft launch for a Season 12 redemption arc. Spoiler alert: She was still let go. Or maybe she was just buying time to figure out what she wanted to do. Personally, I think this is her ploy to move to The Valley. Either way, the timing feels strategic. And that’s a tough pill to swallow coming from someone who’s always insisted she’s a straight shooter.
Scheana Shay is playing chess
Scheana has never claimed to be perfect. But her decision to keep Brock’s cheating a secret feels less like self-preservation and more like selective transparency. On a show where other cast members’ relationships have been picked apart frame by frame, viewers expect and deserve a little more honesty. The silence didn’t spare her from scrutiny either. If anything, it made things worse. If Scheana is heartbroken, at least she is using that emotion productively. Because if there’s one rule in this friend group, it’s this: secrets never stay secret for long. And when they do, it’s usually because someone’s trying to protect the wrong person.
Vanderpump Rules is available to stream on Peacock and Hayu in the UK and Ireland.
TELL US – DO YOU THINK SCHEANA SHOULD HAVE KEPT THE AFFAIR A SECRET?
